Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sarah  Keeler's avatar

There are too many exceptions to the "John = good guy" rule in the Strike series for the theory to hold weight.

See also Inigo John Upcott in The Ink Black Heart. Inigo, objectively a terrible father and human, uses his middle name to chat with young women through his website. The killer in that same novel uses the name John Baldwin as one of his "sock puppet" Twitter. This is one of the final clues that helps Strike and Robin uncover his real identity.

I'm interested in any connections between the Jonathans (a similar but etymologically distinct name from John) symbolically in the books. Jonathan Wace —while absolutely evil — does not turn out to be the perpetrator of the central murder mystery of The Running Grave. Likewise, Jonathan Rokeby — while deeply flawed as a human and father — doesn't turn out to be the monster we first assume.

Sandy Hope's avatar

This is great John, thank you. I love the chiasmus of Rupert's full name with Bernard in the center. A favorite quote from Bernard of Clairvaux: "humility is, of all graces, the chiefest when it does not see itself to be a grace at all." I'd love a reappearance of Rupert as Bernard.

The Savior Garden(er) is to me a cosmic joke of epic proportions. Sacha ignores the saving of family members, and assigns stunt doubles to be the true risk takers. Mary Magdalene mistook Jesus for a gardener (which makes sense given the last time she saw him he was dead), but I don't think anyone would ever mistake Sacha for a gardener! He'd have to get literally dirty, stooping low to care about nurturing a garden, which in his world is below him. Simon suits him well.

When you pointed out Tyler as a doorkeeper, I immediately thought of a Jesus saying "I am the Door," the one who literally lays down (his life) at the opening of the fold in order to protect the sheep within. (Jn 10)

Maybe Ian Griffiths is a case of the longer (9 letters) surname killing the shorter (3letters) given name. He chose to give in to a bestial version of his name; the center letter in Greek would be a phi (ɸ), the antithesis of theta (θ) or God, which suggests that he set himself up much as Lucifer did.

My favorite is your description of Jolanda, the violet flower, symbol of humility. I have violets in my yard, and they are a ground cover, with flowers that bow as if in prayer, whose leaves are shaped like hearts, another prominent Rowling theme.

38 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?